Introduction
If you manage Google Ads, you have probably stared at the ad strength meter and wondered whether it deserves your attention. Google calls it a helpful guide for writing better responsive search ads. A new study of more than 5,900 real Google Ads accounts suggests the meter does far more than guide you. It quietly decides which of your ads gets shown most often, and the ad it favours is not always the one that brings in sales.
Brad Geddes, co-founder of the PPC platform Adalysis, compared responsive search ads inside the same ad groups, where both ads shared the same keywords, bids and budget. The higher rated ad won the impression battle most of the time, yet it had the better conversion rate in only 45 percent of those ad groups. The lower rated ad converted better more often than the higher rated one. With holiday traffic about to peak, that gap is worth your attention. An 11.8 percent difference in cost per acquisition is the difference between a campaign that scales profitably and one that quietly burns budget on clicks that never turn into customers.
What Google Says Ad Strength Is, and What It Is Not
Google’s Help Center describes ad strength as a tool for the ad creation stage. The rating runs from Poor to Excellent and is meant to tell you whether your ad has enough variety and relevance to perform well. Google states plainly that the rating does not directly influence serving eligibility and is not used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score or auction outcomes. Ginny Marvin, Google’s Ads Product Liaison, has said the same in public, writing in a March 2024 post on X that ad strength is not used directly in the auction and should not limit your testing.
Take Google at its word on the mechanics. The rating itself probably never enters the auction formula. But there is a real difference between “the rating is not an auction input” and “the rating has no effect on which ad gets shown.” The traits that lift a rating, more distinct headlines, broader keyword coverage, fewer pinned positions, also give Google’s system more combinations to test when it predicts which ad will earn a click. The label may stay out of the auction, yet the system still leans toward the ad that carries it.
The Head to Head Numbers
The strongest part of the study isolates ad groups with two active responsive search ads carrying different strength ratings. Because both ads share keywords, bids and budget, the comparison strips out most of the noise that usually muddies PPC analysis.
In those ad groups, the higher rated ad received more impressions 63 percent of the time. The gap widens when the ratings are far apart. An Excellent ad beat a Poor ad on impressions in 78 percent of ad groups. Ads separated by two rating steps, such as Excellent versus Average or Good versus Poor, went to the higher rated ad 66 percent of the time. Even the closest matchup, Good versus Average, went to the higher rated ad 59 percent of the time.
Performance told a different story. The higher rated ad had the higher click through rate in 52.5 percent of ad groups, barely better than a coin flip. It had the higher conversion rate in only 45 percent, which means the lower rated ad converted better in 55 percent of ad groups. On conversions per 1,000 impressions, a metric Adalysis calls CPI, the lower rated ad won 54.3 percent of the time. The lower rated ad also had the lower cost per acquisition in 51.5 percent of ad groups, and across all ad groups the higher rated ads ran an 11.8 percent higher CPA. In plain terms, a lower rated ad with a 100 dollar CPA would face a higher rated rival at 111.80 dollars. Geddes’ warning is direct. Google will serve the higher rated ad more often, even if it has a worse conversion rate or CPI, so judge a test only on impressions or clicks and you may declare the wrong winner.
Adalysis ran a similar study in 2022, so the drift is visible. In 2022 the higher rated ad won more impressions in 56.8 percent of ad groups; in 2026 that figure is 63 percent. Its edge on click through rate moved from 48.5 percent to 52.5 percent. But its edge on conversion rate barely moved, from 45.8 percent to 45.1 percent. Google is leaning harder on the higher rated ad when it picks which ad to show, and that pick lines up with clicks a little better than it did four years ago. It does not line up with conversions any better.
Why Pinned Ads Break the Pattern
Before anyone decides ad strength is useless, look at who the lower rated ads actually are. Geddes attributes most of their conversion edge to pinning. In most of the mixed strength ad groups, one ad was pinned and the other was not. Pinned ads tend to earn lower ratings, and they also tend to post higher conversion rates.
That makes sense to anyone who has pinned a headline on purpose. You pin a price, a required disclaimer or a qualifier because you want to filter the click rather than chase it. A pinned headline that says “from 499 dollars” or “for businesses with 50 plus staff” deliberately turns away unqualified searchers. Ad strength rewards variety and keyword coverage, and a pinned ad written to pre-qualify buyers works against both.
The unpinned results look very different. Among unpinned ads, click through rate rose with every step up in ad strength, and so did CPI. Conversion rates rose slightly at each step except the jump from Poor to Average. For those ads, chasing a higher rating generally pays off. So the honest summary is not that ad strength does not matter. It predicts performance well when you leave Google’s system alone, and poorly when you have deliberately overridden it with pins.
How Many Headlines Excellent Actually Takes
Only a third of unpinned ads in the dataset reached Excellent, and the asset counts show why stuffing in headlines will not get you there. Without pinning, an ad can reach Good with as few as seven assets. For Excellent, Geddes recommends at least 11 different headlines. Volume alone does not do it. Only 44 percent of ads with 15 or more headlines reached Excellent, and in the most extreme case, an ad with 38 assets was still rated Poor.
Once you pin, the minimum asset count to reach Good jumps to 10. Pinning two positions now caps an ad at Good and often leaves it at Poor or Average, which is stricter than what Adalysis saw in 2022. If you pin all three headline positions, Geddes suggests aiming for about 13 assets. There is a workaround. Pinning three or more different assets to the same position still leaves room for Excellent, while pinning only one or two caps the ad at Good. Position matters too. Headline one carries more weight than headline two, which carries more than headline three. The practical lesson is that repetition is the silent killer of ad strength. If your ad sits at Average with 15 headlines, the likely culprit is near duplicate copy, so rewrite the repeats before you add more.
What to Change in Your Account This Week
Sort your RSAs by pinning status before you read a single rating. Tag each ad as unpinned, partly pinned or fully pinned in Google Ads Editor or a report export. The rating means something different in each group, so judge each group on its own terms.
Push unpinned ads to Excellent with variety, not volume. Geddes recommends at least 11 headlines that mix keywords, benefits, features, calls to action and authority statements. If an unpinned ad sits at Average with 15 headlines, rewrite the near duplicates before you add more. A fresh angle beats a reworded clone every time.
Rebuild pinned ads instead of abandoning them. Remove the pins, build the ad to Excellent, then re-pin and keep adding assets until the rating reaches at least Average, or Good if you pin a single headline. Where you must pin, pin three or more variations to that position. If you pin all three headlines, plan on about 13 assets.
Judge tests on CPI and CPA, and give mismatched tests more time. It is fine to run ads with different ratings in the same ad group, but expect the lower rated ad to collect far fewer impressions, since an Excellent ad took the impression lead in nearly four of five matchups against a Poor one. That stretches the time it takes to reach statistical significance. If the lower rated, pinned ad wins on CPA, keep it running. Never pause a winner just to fix a label.
Audit before the holiday peak. The 11.8 percent CPA gap is a budget leak you can find in an afternoon. Sort, rebuild the pinned ads that matter most, and let the unpinned ads earn their Excellent rating with genuinely varied copy.
The Bottom Line
Geddes closes his study with a line every PPC manager should keep handy. He writes that often, the human ability to create compelling ads will outperform the machine’s ability to serve the ads properly. One caveat is worth adding. The machine still decides how often your best human written ad gets seen. So treat ad strength as a traffic allocator you have to manage, not a grade you have to win. Check it against your own conversion data, ad group by ad group, and let CPA decide which ad stays. Google tells us what the rating is not. The data from 5,900 accounts tells us what it does.

FAQ
Does a higher ad strength rating mean my ad will convert better?
Not necessarily. The higher rated ad had the better conversion rate in only 45 percent of ad groups. The lower rated ad converted better in 55 percent, largely because many lower rated ads were pinned to pre-qualify clicks.
Does Google use ad strength in the auction?
Google says no. The Help Center states the rating is a guide for ad creation and is not used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score or auction outcomes. The study shows the higher rated ad still gets served more often, likely because the traits that raise the rating give Google’s system more combinations to work with.
Should I stop pinning headlines in my responsive search ads?
No, but pin with intent. Pin a price, disclaimer or qualifier when you need to control the message or filter unqualified clicks. Know that pinning lowers the rating and reduces impressions, so judge pinned ads on CPA and CPI rather than on their strength label.
How many headlines do I need for an Excellent rating?
Geddes recommends at least 11 distinct headlines for an unpinned ad. If you pin all three headline positions, aim for about 13 assets. Variety matters more than volume. Only 44 percent of ads with 15 or more headlines reached Excellent, so rewrite near duplicates before adding more.
How should I judge an ad test when the ads have different strength ratings?
Judge on conversions per 1,000 impressions and cost per acquisition, not on impressions or clicks. Expect the lower rated ad to collect fewer impressions, so give the test more time to reach significance. If the lower rated ad wins on CPA, keep it running.
Is ad strength worth improving at all?
Yes, for unpinned ads. Among unpinned ads, click through rate and conversions per 1,000 impressions rose with every step up in rating. The rating is a useful guide when you let Google’s system work freely. It becomes misleading only when pins override that system.